[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Old Index]
Re: proposed package removal: mail/dovecot (1.2.17)
from Greg Troxel:
> My impression is that pretty much everyone using dovecot runs
> mail/dovecot2 which is now at 2.2.28, and that this has been true for a
> very long time.
> mail/dovecot is at 1.2.17, and was updated to that version on
> 2011-05-13. About a month later the sieve version was updated. The
> only real change since then was a CVE remediation patch on 2015-01-23.
> Plus revbumps, SMF fixes, and other minor maintenance that does indicate
> that upstream is paying attention or that there are real users.
> Is anyone using it? Could you explain why? Would anybody object to
> removing the package? Please feel free to object/explain in private
> mail if it's too embarassing (but this is a clue) and if any I'll report
> the count of anonymous objectors and their reasons here.
> Please note that I am not proposing to rename mail/dovecot2. My view is
> usually that once a package needs to have two versions, that's likely a
> condition for life, and renaming PKGNAME hurts more than it helps. I am
> merely trying to avoid someone doing "cd /usr/pkgsrc/mail/dovecot &&
> make replace" by accident.
> If there are no objections, I'll remove mail/dovecot, no earlier than a
> week from now: 2017-04-06 0100Z.
With regard to renaming, FreeBSD ports has ways to rename a port/package without severe disruption.
Portupgrade and portmaster can update a port/package whose name has changed, like if dovecot2 were renamed to dovecot:
portupgrade -o mail/dovecot2 mail/dovecot
portmaster -o mail/dovecot2 mail/dovecot
also, pkg can rename a package's entry in the package database:
pkg set -o mail/dovecot2:mail/dovecot or
pkg set -n dovecot2:dovecot
I believe pkg was ported to (NetBSD) pkgsrc recently, along with synth.
This pkg (pkgng) is not package-database-compatible with the older pkg_* tools.
I don't see much if anything on the newer pkg or John Marino's synth on this list, pkgsrc-users or tech-pkg.
But still better not to rename a package without good reason.
That said, I don't use the old, outdated dovecot 1.2.17.
Main Index |
Thread Index |