NetBSD-Bugs archive

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Old Index]

Re: kern/45918: No sound with -current hdaudio(4) on Realtek ALC892 but works with netbsd-5 azalia(4)




See also:  kern/45862

On Fri, Feb 03, 2012 at 03:50:00AM +0000, Matthew Mondor wrote:
> >Number:         45918
> >Category:       kern
> >Synopsis:       No sound with -current hdaudio(4) on Realtek ALC892 but 
> >works with netbsd-5 azalia(4)
> >Confidential:   no
> >Severity:       serious
> >Priority:       medium
> >Responsible:    kern-bug-people
> >State:          open
> >Class:          sw-bug
> >Submitter-Id:   net
> >Arrival-Date:   Fri Feb 03 03:50:00 +0000 2012
> >Originator:     Matthew Mondor
> >Release:        NetBSD 5.99.63
> >Organization:
> >Environment:
> NetBSD 5.99.63 (GENERIC) #2: Thu Feb 2 05:57:31 EST 2012
> Architecture: amd64
> Machine: amd64
> >Description:
> 
> Although azalia(4) works fine on netbsd-5 for this chip, I cannot
> produce sound with the hdaudio(4) driver on -current.
> 
> daudio0 at pci0 dev 27 function 0: HD Audio Controller
> hdaudio0: interrupting at ioapic0 pin 22
> hdafg0 at hdaudio0: Realtek ALC892
> hdafg0: DAC00 8ch: Speaker [Jack]
> hdafg0: DAC01 2ch: HP Out [Jack]
> hdafg0: DIG02 2ch: SPDIF Out [Jack]
> hdafg0: DIG03 2ch: SPDIF Out [Built-In]
> hdafg0: ADC04 2ch: Line In [Jack], Mic In [Jack]
> hdafg0: ADC05 2ch: Mic In [Jack]
> hdafg0: 8ch/2ch 32000Hz 44100Hz 48000Hz 88200Hz 96000Hz 192000Hz PCM16 PCM20 
> PCM24 AC3
> audio0 at hdafg0: full duplex, playback, capture, independent
> 
> name=Realtek
> version=ALC892
> config=01h
> encodings=slinear_le:16,slinear_be:16*,ulinear_le:16*,ulinear_be:16*,mulaw:8*,alaw:8*,slinear_le:32,slinear_be:32*,ulinear_le:32*,ulinear_be:32*,ac3:16
> properties=full_duplex,independent
> full_duplex=0
> fullduplex=0
> blocksize=8192
> hiwat=8
> lowat=1
> monitor_gain=0
> mode=
> play.rate=44100
> play.channels=1
> play.precision=16
> play.encoding=slinear_le
> play.gain=192
> play.balance=32
> play.port=0x0
> play.avail_ports=0x0
> play.seek=0
> play.samples=0
> play.eof=0
> play.pause=0
> play.error=0
> play.waiting=0
> play.open=0
> play.active=0
> play.buffer_size=65536
> record.rate=8000
> record.channels=1
> record.precision=8
> record.encoding=mulaw
> record.gain=0
> record.balance=32
> record.port=0x0
> record.avail_ports=0x0
> record.seek=0
> record.samples=0
> record.eof=0
> record.pause=0
> record.error=0
> record.waiting=0
> record.open=0
> record.active=0
> record.buffer_size=65536
> record.errors=0
> 
> outputs.master=192,192
> outputs.master2=192,192
> outputs.master3=192,192
> outputs.master4=192,192
> inputs.reclvl=80,80
> inputs.reclvl.mute=off
> inputs.reclvl2=80,80
> inputs.reclvl2.mute=off
> inputs.record=184,184
> inputs.record.mute=off
> inputs.record2=184,184
> inputs.record2.mute=off
> inputs.record3=184,184
> inputs.record3.mute=off
> inputs.beep=184,184
> inputs.beep.mute=off
> outputs.master5=0,0
> outputs.master5.mute=off
> outputs.master6=0,0
> outputs.master6.mute=off
> outputs.master7=0,0
> outputs.master7.mute=off
> outputs.master8=0,0
> outputs.master8.mute=off
> outputs.master9=0,0
> outputs.master9.mute=off
> outputs.master10=0,0
> outputs.master10.mute=off
> outputs.master11=0,0
> outputs.master11.mute=off
> outputs.master12=0,0
> outputs.master12.mute=off
> outputs.master13=0,0
> outputs.master13.mute=off
> outputs.master14=0,0
> outputs.master14.mute=off
> outputs.master15=0,0
> outputs.master15.mute=off
> outputs.master16=0,0
> outputs.master16.mute=off
> record.mic=0,0
> record.monitor=0,0
> inputs.line=0,0
> outputs.master17=0,0
> outputs.master17.mute=off
> inputs.reclvl3=0,0
> inputs.reclvl3.mute=off
> inputs.beep2=0,0
> inputs.beep2.mute=off
> inputs.record4=0,0
> inputs.record4.mute=off
> inputs.beep3=0,0
> inputs.beep3.mute=off
> record.mic2=0,0
> record.mic2.mute=off
> inputs.line2=0,0
> inputs.line2.mute=off
> inputs.beep4=0,0
> inputs.beep4.mute=off
> inputs.record5=0,0
> inputs.record5.mute=off
> outputs.master18=192,192
> outputs.master19=0,0
> outputs.master19.mute=off
> outputs.master20=0,0
> outputs.master20.mute=off
> outputs.dacsel=DAC00,DAC01,DIG02,DIG03
> record.source=ADC04,ADC05
> 
> 
> codecid 0x00 nid 0x01 vendor 0x10EC product 0x0892 subsystem 0x841B1043 
> device hdafg0
> 
> <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
> <!DOCTYPE plist PUBLIC "-//Apple Computer//DTD PLIST 1.0//EN" 
> "http://www.apple.com/DTDs/PropertyList-1.0.dtd";>
> <plist version="1.0">
> <array>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x99430140</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>17</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x411111f0</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>18</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x1114010</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>20</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x1111012</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>21</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x1116011</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>22</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x1112014</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>23</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x1a19850</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>24</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x2a19c60</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>25</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x181305f</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>26</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x2214c20</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>27</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x411111f0</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>28</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x4015e601</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>29</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x1456130</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>30</integer>
>       </dict>
>       <dict>
>               <key>config</key>
>               <integer>0x411111f0</integer>
>               <key>nid</key>
>               <integer>31</integer>
>       </dict>
> </array>
> </plist>
> 
> digraph "HD Audio 10EC:0892" {
>  widget02h [label="widget02h\naudio 
> output",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget03h [label="widget03h\naudio 
> output",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget04h [label="widget04h\naudio 
> output",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget05h [label="widget05h\naudio 
> output",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget06h [label="widget06h\naudio 
> output",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget07h [label="widget07h\nvendor defined",shape=box];
>  widget08h [label="widget08h\naudio 
> input",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#ff8888"];
>  widget23h -> widget08h [sametail=widget23h];
>  widget09h [label="widget09h\naudio 
> input",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#ff8888"];
>  widget22h -> widget09h [sametail=widget22h];
>  widget0Ah [label="widget0Ah\naudio 
> input",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#ff8888"];
>  widget1Fh -> widget0Ah [sametail=widget1Fh];
>  widget0Bh [label="widget0Bh\naudio mixer",shape=invhouse];
>  widget18h -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget18h];
>  widget19h -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget19h];
>  widget1Ah -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget1Ah];
>  widget1Bh -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget1Bh];
>  widget1Ch -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget1Ch];
>  widget1Dh -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget1Dh];
>  widget14h -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget14h];
>  widget15h -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget15h];
>  widget16h -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget16h];
>  widget17h -> widget0Bh [sametail=widget17h];
>  widget0Ch [label="widget0Ch\naudio mixer",shape=invhouse];
>  widget02h -> widget0Ch [sametail=widget02h];
>  widget0Bh -> widget0Ch [sametail=widget0Bh];
>  widget0Dh [label="widget0Dh\naudio mixer",shape=invhouse];
>  widget03h -> widget0Dh [sametail=widget03h];
>  widget0Bh -> widget0Dh [sametail=widget0Bh];
>  widget0Eh [label="widget0Eh\naudio mixer",shape=invhouse];
>  widget04h -> widget0Eh [sametail=widget04h];
>  widget0Bh -> widget0Eh [sametail=widget0Bh];
>  widget0Fh [label="widget0Fh\naudio mixer",shape=invhouse];
>  widget05h -> widget0Fh [sametail=widget05h];
>  widget0Bh -> widget0Fh [sametail=widget0Bh];
>  widget10h [label="widget10h\naudio 
> output",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget11h [label="widget11h\ndevice=SPDIF 
> Out",style=filled,shape=circle,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget10h -> widget11h [sametail=widget10h];
>  widget12h [label="widget12h\nbeep generator",shape=box];
>  widget13h [label="widget13h\nvendor defined",shape=box];
>  widget14h 
> [label="widget14h\ndevice=Speaker",style=filled,shape=doublecircle,fillcolor="#ffff88"];
>  widget0Ch -> widget14h [sametail=widget0Ch];
>  widget15h 
> [label="widget15h\ndevice=Speaker",style=filled,shape=doublecircle,fillcolor="#ffff88"];
>  widget0Dh -> widget15h [sametail=widget0Dh];
>  widget16h 
> [label="widget16h\ndevice=Speaker",style=filled,shape=doublecircle,fillcolor="#ffff88"];
>  widget0Eh -> widget16h [sametail=widget0Eh];
>  widget17h 
> [label="widget17h\ndevice=Speaker",style=filled,shape=doublecircle,fillcolor="#ffff88"];
>  widget0Fh -> widget17h [sametail=widget0Fh];
>  widget18h [label="widget18h\ndevice=Mic 
> In",style=filled,shape=doublecircle,fillcolor="#ffff88"];
>  widget0Ch -> widget18h [sametail=widget0Ch];
>  widget0Dh -> widget18h [sametail=widget0Dh];
>  widget0Eh -> widget18h [sametail=widget0Eh];
>  widget0Fh -> widget18h [sametail=widget0Fh];
>  widget26h -> widget18h [sametail=widget26h];
>  widget19h [label="widget19h\ndevice=Mic 
> In",style=filled,shape=doublecircle,fillcolor="#ffff88"];
>  widget0Ch -> widget19h [sametail=widget0Ch];
>  widget0Dh -> widget19h [sametail=widget0Dh];
>  widget0Eh -> widget19h [sametail=widget0Eh];
>  widget0Fh -> widget19h [sametail=widget0Fh];
>  widget26h -> widget19h [sametail=widget26h];
>  widget1Ah [label="widget1Ah\ndevice=Line 
> In",style=filled,shape=doublecircle,fillcolor="#ffff88"];
>  widget0Ch -> widget1Ah [sametail=widget0Ch];
>  widget0Dh -> widget1Ah [sametail=widget0Dh];
>  widget0Eh -> widget1Ah [sametail=widget0Eh];
>  widget0Fh -> widget1Ah [sametail=widget0Fh];
>  widget26h -> widget1Ah [sametail=widget26h];
>  widget1Bh [label="widget1Bh\ndevice=HP 
> Out",style=filled,shape=doublecircle,fillcolor="#ffff88"];
>  widget0Ch -> widget1Bh [sametail=widget0Ch];
>  widget0Dh -> widget1Bh [sametail=widget0Dh];
>  widget0Eh -> widget1Bh [sametail=widget0Eh];
>  widget0Fh -> widget1Bh [sametail=widget0Fh];
>  widget26h -> widget1Bh [sametail=widget26h];
>  widget1Ch [label="widget1Ch\nbeep generator",shape=box];
>  widget1Dh 
> [label="widget1Dh\ndevice=Speaker",style=filled,shape=circle,fillcolor="#ff8888"];
>  widget1Eh [label="widget1Eh\ndevice=SPDIF 
> Out",style=filled,shape=circle,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget06h -> widget1Eh [sametail=widget06h];
>  widget1Fh [label="widget1Fh\nbeep generator",shape=box];
>  widget20h [label="widget20h\nvendor defined",shape=box];
>  widget21h [label="widget21h\nvendor defined",shape=box];
>  widget22h [label="widget22h\naudio mixer",shape=invhouse];
>  widget18h -> widget22h [sametail=widget18h];
>  widget19h -> widget22h [sametail=widget19h];
>  widget1Ah -> widget22h [sametail=widget1Ah];
>  widget1Bh -> widget22h [sametail=widget1Bh];
>  widget1Ch -> widget22h [sametail=widget1Ch];
>  widget1Dh -> widget22h [sametail=widget1Dh];
>  widget14h -> widget22h [sametail=widget14h];
>  widget15h -> widget22h [sametail=widget15h];
>  widget16h -> widget22h [sametail=widget16h];
>  widget17h -> widget22h [sametail=widget17h];
>  widget0Bh -> widget22h [sametail=widget0Bh];
>  widget12h -> widget22h [sametail=widget12h];
>  widget23h [label="widget23h\naudio mixer",shape=invhouse];
>  widget18h -> widget23h [sametail=widget18h];
>  widget19h -> widget23h [sametail=widget19h];
>  widget1Ah -> widget23h [sametail=widget1Ah];
>  widget1Bh -> widget23h [sametail=widget1Bh];
>  widget1Ch -> widget23h [sametail=widget1Ch];
>  widget1Dh -> widget23h [sametail=widget1Dh];
>  widget14h -> widget23h [sametail=widget14h];
>  widget15h -> widget23h [sametail=widget15h];
>  widget16h -> widget23h [sametail=widget16h];
>  widget17h -> widget23h [sametail=widget17h];
>  widget0Bh -> widget23h [sametail=widget0Bh];
>  widget24h [label="widget24h\nvendor defined",shape=box];
>  widget25h [label="widget25h\naudio 
> output",shape=box,style=filled,fillcolor="#88ff88"];
>  widget26h [label="widget26h\naudio mixer",shape=invhouse];
>  widget25h -> widget26h [sametail=widget25h];
>  widget0Bh -> widget26h [sametail=widget0Bh];
>  {rank=min;}
>  {rank=max;}
> }
> 
> >How-To-Repeat:
> >Fix:
> 
> >Unformatted:
>  To: gnats-bugs%gnats.NetBSD.org@localhost
>  Subject: No sound with -current hdaudio(4) on Realtek ALC892 but works with 
> netbsd-5 azalia(4)
>  From: mm_lists%pulsar-zone.net@localhost
>  Reply-To: mm_lists%pulsar-zone.net@localhost
>  X-send-pr-version: 3.95
>  
>  

-- 
Brad Harder
Method Logic Digital Consulting
http://methodlogic.net/
http://twitter.com/bcharder



Home | Main Index | Thread Index | Old Index