Subject: Re: kern/32405
To: None <kern-bug-people@netbsd.org, gnats-admin@netbsd.org,>
From: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?St=E9phane_Witzmann?= <stephane.witzmann@gmail.com>
List: netbsd-bugs
Date: 12/29/2005 04:15:06
The following reply was made to PR kern/32405; it has been noted by GNATS.

From: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?St=E9phane_Witzmann?= <stephane.witzmann@gmail.com>
To: gnats-bugs@netbsd.org
Cc: 
Subject: Re: kern/32405
Date: Thu, 29 Dec 2005 05:10:29 +0100

 Well, I had it fail (ie not work with getoptr) with 3.0 on my USB
 sound card too, but only on a few videos (always the same ones,
 hopefully).
 
 Since we now know that this PR is NOT about auich(4) but more general,
 it sounds like a good idea to rename it.
 
 
 I also ran additional tests, I compared the output of "audioctl -a"
 with 2.1 and 3.0 when playing the same video, one which doesn't work
 with 3.0.
 
 2.1 says:
 name=3DICH4 AC97
 version=3D0x03
 config=3Dauich0
 encodings=3Dulinear:8*,mulaw:8*,alaw:8*,slinear:8*,slinear_le:16,ulinear_le=
 :16*,slinear_be:16*,ulinear_be:16*
 properties=3Dfull_duplex,independent
 full_duplex=3D0
 fullduplex=3D0
 blocksize=3D9600
 hiwat=3D6
 lowat=3D4
 monitor_gain=3D0
 mode=3Dplay
 play.rate=3D44100
 play.channels=3D1
 play.precision=3D16
 play.encoding=3Dslinear_le
 play.gain=3D127
 play.balance=3D32
 play.port=3D0x0
 play.avail_ports=3D0x0
 play.seek=3D57596
 play.samples=3D2707200
 play.eof=3D0
 play.pause=3D0
 play.error=3D0
 play.waiting=3D0
 play.open=3D1
 play.active=3D1
 play.buffer_size=3D65536
 record.rate=3D44100
 record.channels=3D1
 record.precision=3D16
 record.encoding=3Dslinear_le
 record.gain=3D0
 record.balance=3D32
 record.port=3D0x1
 record.avail_ports=3D0x7
 record.seek=3D0
 record.samples=3D0
 record.eof=3D0
 record.pause=3D0
 record.error=3D0
 record.waiting=3D0
 record.open=3D0
 record.active=3D0
 record.buffer_size=3D65536
 record.errors=3D0
 
 and 3.0 says:
 name=3DICH4 AC97
 version=3D0x03
 config=3Dauich0
 encodings=3Dslinear_le:16,slinear_be:16*,ulinear_le:16*,ulinear_be:16*,mula=
 w:8*,alaw:8*
 properties=3Dfull_duplex,independent
 full_duplex=3D0
 fullduplex=3D0
 blocksize=3D9600
 hiwat=3D6
 lowat=3D5
 monitor_gain=3D0
 mode=3Dplay
 play.rate=3D44100
 play.channels=3D1
 play.precision=3D16
 play.encoding=3Dslinear_le
 play.gain=3D119
 play.balance=3D32
 play.port=3D0x0
 play.avail_ports=3D0x0
 play.seek=3D0
 play.samples=3D4290948852
 play.eof=3D0
 play.pause=3D0
 play.error=3D1
 play.waiting=3D0
 play.open=3D1
 play.active=3D1
 play.buffer_size=3D65536
 record.rate=3D44100
 record.channels=3D1
 record.precision=3D16
 record.encoding=3Dslinear_le
 record.gain=3D0
 record.balance=3D32
 record.port=3D0x1
 record.avail_ports=3D0x7
 record.seek=3D0
 record.samples=3D0
 record.eof=3D0
 record.pause=3D0
 record.error=3D0
 record.waiting=3D0
 record.open=3D0
 record.active=3D0
 record.buffer_size=3D65536
 record.errors=3D0
 
 
 diff points out that :
 - play.error=3D1
 - play.samples is huge
 - lowat (what is it ?) changed from 4 to 5