Subject: Re: tar arguments
To: None <conklin@kaleida.com>
From: Alistair G. Crooks <agc@uts.amdahl.com>
List: netbsd-bugs
Date: 01/20/1994 00:38:21
I haven't seen the original of this article, so I'm only commenting on
the followup.
> dgy> "INSTALLATION NOTES for NetBSD/i386" reference the following
> dgy> commands to list and extract the contents of the distribution
> dgy> archives, respectively:
> dgy> cat set_name.??? | gunzip | tar tf -
> dgy> cat set_name.??? | gunzip | tar xvfp -
> dgy> Instead, these should read:
> dgy> cat set_name.??? | gunzip | tar -tf -
> dgy> cat set_name.??? | gunzip | tar -xvpf - (order of f & p reversed!)
>
> Historically tar has not used '-' to indicate command line options.
> Modern versions of tar, including GNU tar (which we are using), allow
> either syntax.
The GNU tar that NetBSD uses allows the use of the 'z' argument to
indicate that the archive is a compressed one, so can anyone see why
the extraction command shouldn't be modified to read :
cat set_name.* | tar xvzfp -
Purely in the interest of less typos, you understand.
Alistair
--
Alistair G. Crooks (agc@uts.amdahl.com) +44 252 346377
Amdahl European HQ, Dogmersfield Park, Hartley Wintney, Hants RG27 8TE, UK.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------