--gDjY2bUXmwR4focy
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

On Tue, Jun 29, 2004 at 04:41:26PM +0900, Jun-ichiro itojun Hagino wrote:
  | > Hi Itojun.
  | >=20
  | > For consistency with the way that we're moving to maintain other
  | > third party software in our tree, could you please:
  |=20
  | 	question: consistency with what?  is there any written description,
  | 	or is it your personal preference/rule?  i don't see any prior art on
  | 	this "consistency" thing, so i have no motivation/justification to
  | 	follow your recommendation.  anyways, here are my comments.  i won't
  | 	bother to commit/re-import.

Consistency with at least the following 3rd party products:
	amd
	bind
	dhcp
	ipf
	ntp
	postfix
	sendmail

That is _significant_ prior art in our tree for this type of software.


  | >     1.	Reimport
  | > 		pf.os
  | > 		pf.conf
  | > 		spamd.conf
  | > 	into=20
  | > 		dist/pf/examples
  |=20
  | 	pf.os is OS fingerprint database, therefore I really want to keep it
  | 	in /etc (just like /etc/moduli used by ssh).

Well, it will need a special handling if we implement
MKIPFILTER/MKPF method proposed in a PR (by Peter Postma ?)


  | >     3.	Reimport
  | > 		pflog.4
  | > 		pf.4
  | > 		pf.os.5
  | > 		pf.conf.5
  | > 		spamd.conf.5
  | > 	into
  | > 		dist/pf/man
  | > 	and remove them from
  | > 		share/man/man[45]
  | >=20
  | >     	Create a reachover Makefiles under
  | > 		usr.sbin/pf/man
  | > 	to install these manual pages
  | >=20
  | >=20
  | >     4.	Relocate the following directories
  | > 		sbin/pfctl		-> usr.sbin/pf/pfctl
  | > 		libexec/ftp-proxy	-> usr.sbin/pf/ftp-proxy
  | > 		libexec/spamd		-> usr.sbin/pf/spamd
  | > 		libexec/spamd-setup	-> usr.sbin/pf/spamd-setup
  | > 		libexec/spamlogd	-> usr.sbin/pf/spamlogd
  | > 		usr.sbin/authpf		-> usr.sbin/pf/authpf
  | > 		usr.sbin/spamdb		-> usr.sbin/pf/spamdb
  | > 	(even though they can still be installed in the
  | > 	same /sbin, /usr/libexec & /usr/sbin locations)
  |=20
  | 	i do not see benefit of 3 and 4.  4 is just for confuse people
  | 	work on PF source code.

Besides the consistency with other 3rd party tools in our tree,
it also makes it far easier to implement a MKPF build switch.

--gDjY2bUXmwR4focy
Content-Type: application/pgp-signature
Content-Disposition: inline

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.4 (NetBSD)

iD8DBQFA4R/wpBhtmn8zJHIRAmIzAJ9QD9fVRWftlM/WCwDQKB1I2qvu6ACdE+l6
kd6dTNNkW/HG2BaDA0cUVwI=
=Cmdd
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--gDjY2bUXmwR4focy--