tech-pkg archive

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Old Index]

Re: Fixing catman pages

On Sat, 07 Sep 2013 23:29:34 +0900, Jonathan Perkin 
<> wrote:

* On 2013-09-07 at 12:43 BST, OBATA Akio wrote:

On Fri, 06 Sep 2013 21:35:28 +0900, Jonathan Perkin 
<> wrote:

> #1: Use mdocml as the tool replacement for nroff.
> =================================================
>  Some packages which generate catman pages ('pkgin', for example) add
>  a USE_TOOLS dependency on nroff, which currently will pull in groff.
>  Whilst this works, it is not ideal as groff has many dependencies,
>  and when adding catman support to e.g. devel/tradcpp we run into
>  circular dependency issues.
>  To fix this, two changesets are required.  First, allow mdocml and
>  groff to co-exist, so that 'USE_TOOLS= groff nroff' will work
>  correctly.  This involves renaming some of mdocml's files:
>  Secondly, use mdocml for USE_TOOLS=nroff:
>  This should have benefits regardless of catman issues, as mdocml is
>  much smaller than groff and is BSD licensed.

How about change to install nroff from groff as `gnroff' instead,
same as other GNU packages?

What would be the benefit of that?  That would be out of scope for the
changes I've proposed, so I'd rather see that discussed separately if
there is a reason for doing so.

Because your change means that nroff from mdocml is the default nroff in pkgsrc,
so I feel that nroff from mdocml should be kept as `nroff' and nroff from groff
should be renamed instead.
`gnroff' is found in pkgsrc/mk/tools/, so isn't it so specal 

OBATA Akio /

Home | Main Index | Thread Index | Old Index