Subject: Re: official logo proposal
To: Dieter Baron <dillo@NetBSD.org>
From: Louis Guillaume <email@example.com>
Date: 09/17/2007 09:11:05
Dieter Baron wrote:
> we (pkgsrc PMC) have been asked to decide on an official logo for
> pkgsrc. We are happy to present a candidate here.
> The last thread on tech-pkg produced two basic logo designs. While
> the folding paper box design by Thomas Bieg is very original and
> expresses elegantly what pkgsrc is about, it is a rather complex
> design with many small parts; it would not work well in small sizes,
> or on buttons or t-shirts. Therefore, we propose the simpler design
> by Chris Wareham (based on the older design by Hubert Feyrer).
> Since the box had problems with perspective and the provided EPS was
> rather large, I recreated the logo. Please review the result at
> Your comments are welcome.
I find this looks awful clunky. It looks thrown together. There are 2
elements that do not relate to each other: an edge-less box and the word
"pkgsrc" in a bulky roundy font. There's also something strange going on
with the perspective of that cube.
And the 3D-ness of the cube does not blend well with the flatness of the
text. This will not be easy to work with in context of printed or
I *much* prefer Thomas Bieg's design, which was a paper cut-out for a
box marked "pkgsrc". This is clever and the presentation looks finished.
I even printed it out and made a box and it looks good! It's flat yet
suggests the "source" for a 3-dimensional object.
In the last discussion Thomas Bieg's logo seemed to be more liked by
those who commented too.
His site is still up: http://www.3tb.de/pkgsrc/logo.html
The site shows that this logo is very versatile.