Subject: Re: Please stop change logs in CVS commit messages
To: Alistair Crooks <email@example.com>
From: David Burgess <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Date: 07/10/2001 13:47:18
Having done CM for years (I ran a company called "Configuration
Management Services, Inc.) I have to add that I'd much rather see
something like "The follow PRs were closed by this update..." followed
by a list of the numbers and a short explanation of how.
A CVS update like "Fixed a bunch of broken stuff" is insufficient.
A rambling, chatty-cathy description of every line of changed code is
too much. There has got to be a happy summary limit in there someplace.
Alistair Crooks wrote:
> On Tue, Jul 10, 2001 at 02:49:47PM -0400, Todd Vierling wrote:
> > This practice of committing with changelogs has got to stop. People have
> > asked why I think it's a stupid idea and have "suggested" that I do so in my
> > commits, and I'm continuing to refuse to do so. Attached you'll find a
> > perfect counterexample that shows how unreasonable this policy is.
> Au contraire, the practice of committing a SUMMARY of the changes
> to the previous version stays in place.
> You would be far better asking the person who comitted the large
> summary very kindly, in private mail, to be a bit more succinct.
> Whilst I agree that 40K is a tad verbose as a precis, people who do
> not add a SUMMARY of the changes will be kindly asked to modify the
> commit message after the fact.
> Thanks for your cooperation,
> > All this does is add a lot more clutter to CVS files, and has very little
> > advantage otherwise. Remember that if you commit with a big commit message,
> > *every* file touched with that commit grows by that amount in the CVS
> > repository.
> > Leave documentation files to provide documentation. That's not what CVS
> > commit logs are meant to hold. If you want more descriptive change log
> > entries, how about a short manually written note that describes why a
> > package is added or upgraded? (And yes, "many bug fixes" should be
> > sufficient.)
> > : Module Name: doc
> > : Committed By: nra
> > : Date: Tue Jul 10 17:53:18 UTC 2001
> > :
> > : Modified Files:
> > : doc: pkg-CHANGES
> > :
> > : Log Message:
> > : Note update of xpmroot to version 2.4.0. PR #13374 by Martti Kuparinen.
> > :
> > [*40K* of change log entries]
> > --
> > -- Todd Vierling <email@example.com> * Wasabi NetBSD: Run with it.
> > -- NetBSD 1.5 now available on CD-ROM -- http://www.wasabisystems.com/