-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Hello, On Jun 9, 2008, at 17:26, Manuel Bouyer wrote:
On Mon, Jun 09, 2008 at 05:15:23PM -0400, Michael Lorenz wrote:On Jun 9, 2008, at 16:16, Manuel Bouyer wrote:On Mon, Jun 09, 2008 at 03:43:05PM -0400, Michael Lorenz wrote:I just did that. Now the kernel doesn't find /any/ USB devices except the root hubs. It can't really be a problem with crimeinterrupts - ehci finds devices and other cards that used interrupt10 worked before so at least one of the uhcis should work.Hmm, an old, unpatched kernel does find devices at uhci.thanks. That's strange: if I read things properly, all the memory usedby uhci or ehci should be mapped uncached (use of BUS_DMA_COHERENT),so the _sync operations I added should just issue wmb() instructions,nothing more.The O2 doesn't have any kind of DMA coherency support IIRC. The only other card I tried in this machine is an ex which Just Worked(tm). So do the onboard ahc's.what do you mean ? bus_dmamap_sync() isn't a NOP, and for cached memoryit has to invalidate or flush the cache.
I meant just that ;)
BTW, I suspect the lack of memory read/write barrier are the cause ofthe issues I'm seeing on x86 too (this is why I started this work).Hmm, I need to read sgimips' bus_dma stuff again but since other drivers work it can't be all that borked.Sure it was not my point. It's most probably an issue with the_sync() calls I added. But as the memory referred to by these calls should be mapped uncached anyway, I don't understand how they could make a difference.
Something's weird here - I added the KASSERT you asked for, didn't add ehci back but the kernel found the USB disk this time. It did hang while probing a low speed device though ( sat there for a minute or so ), when I unplugged it the machine booted normally and so far bonnie's been working for about 10 minutes without any trouble. For some reason it took a lot longer than on my other machines to find the USB disk ( ~15 seconds vs. less than one )
have fun Michael -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.7 (Darwin) iQEVAwUBSE2j5MpnzkX8Yg2nAQJEQgf/T+HyJ7dMjSbXCgIz2v4gi1YrJ/Dp7SpB My1Sg3MrTtKTHCfwieVcn5cWXGhLs252onbcSB4GpHRa2hMydPUo29zlzcsIJIdP MXjh2YGrktjP/l8hyURMqlW4qML8xKIstSekKmPPR5blJtIelrZKvPklWrThtLmh xwDXD0QSJrlzm9p+/ELRrjC2vyMb42+9QzbJZ9cAfVMWaE7PJUCC7bEAVNOeMVjL HxElFa0S2BdW0/UHM6OjY/+/uNG/nflucYyma0G9fgbIQBBZHsPGmYNbAdhlfUsh ifckev2Q6bLSNrlJWeygTyOefklv8RAY6QvJm+edT8V9Fsk6gdToug== =wOnZ -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----