Subject: Re: proposal for non-512 bytes/sector block device
To: Jason Thorpe <firstname.lastname@example.org>
From: Noriyuki Soda <email@example.com>
Date: 06/27/1997 05:24:33
In short, Koji Imada provides 3 different solutions to solve this
5.1. use physical sector size as abstraction. (PR kern/3790)
5.2. use DEV_BSIZE as abstraction. (PR kern/3791)
5.3. permit any sector size. (PR kern/3792)
>>>>> On Thu, 26 Jun 1997 10:20:24 -0700,
Jason Thorpe <firstname.lastname@example.org> said:
> I agree with Matt, here... Basically, it's _very_ convenient to assume
> DEV_BSIZE in the rest of the kernel as, basically, an abstraction.
In other words, you like his solution 5.2. (PR kern/3791)
Is this right ?
I like his solution 5.1. (PR kern/3790), because:
- device driver should provide what the device are.
It seems somewhat wasteful that all device drivers do blocking and
deblocking to support DEV_BSIZE abstraction.
If there are N devices and M real file systems, always N > M.
(I actually use only 3 real file systems. i.e. ffs, msdosfs, cd9660).
So, file system layer should deal with various block sizes, not
device driver layer.
- As showed by his kern/3790, essentially, ffs and msdosfs are already
able to deal with the filesystems which block size != 512, and
cd9660 file system's block size != 512.
- kern/3790 is simplest (shortest) one.
And, it seems that fixed (512 bytes) length abstraction is not modern...
> Koji-san has caught the file system cases. But, what about the swap
> pager? What about raw i/o?
I think he already provides raw i/o fix, and probably swap pager could
use d_secsize field of swap device's disklabel.
BTW, Non-512 bytes block devices are very popular in Japan.
(e.g. 2048 bytes/sector Magneto-Optical disk, 1024 bytes/sector floppy
disk, 256 bytes/sector HDD, and DVD will be also 2048 bytes/sector).
So, we Japanese are all eagerly looking forward to this fix.
I've heard that Koji likes solution 5.3 (kern/3792), :-)
Undoubtedly 5.3 is most flexible solution. (e.g. cd9660fs on HDD).
But I think it could be solved by his vnode disk driver (it provides
sector size conversion).