Subject: Re: NetBSD logo design competition
To: Johan A.van Zanten <johan@giantfoo.org>
From: Florian <netbsd@wolfnode.de>
List: netbsd-users
Date: 01/16/2004 03:54:20
damn, that tatoo is REALLY cool!
Well, but on the human body, there are 2mē room, so enough space for
upcoming new BSD logos ;-)
And again a vote for keeping the daemon!
Florian
Johan A.van Zanten wrote:
> "Ian Harding" <ianh@tpchd.org> wrote:
>
>>God I wish it was. I got told in no uncertain terms to take the logo
>>off our internal intranet site. It offended some prissy people. We
>>have to cater to the prissiest among us. It makes me want to puke.
>
>
> "Jesus HP Laser Jet Christ!"
>
> Oh, i guess i can't say that either...
>
>
>>So, will we be the only *BSD without the beastie?
>
>
> As others have pointed out, OpenBSD and DragonflyBSD have both switched
> to other characters. (Partially or entirely.)
>
> However, unlike OpenBSD or DragonflyBSD, NetBSD was (more-or-less) a
> continuation of the BSD project (rather than a fork of another BSD-derived
> project), and dropping the mascot of that program suggests to me that
> perhaps NetBSD no longer cares about that lineage and history.
>
> The acronym "BSD" and the daemon image are tightly coupled in my
> mind. Perhaps when getting rid of the BSD mascot, NetBSD should also
> remove the "BSD" from its name? But being just "Net" seems kinda
> silly. So then perhaps become "YACFULOS" ("Yet Another Collaborative Free
> Unix-Like Operating System") or something.
>
> I'm greatly saddened by this. And i'm not just saying this because i
> have the 4.3 BSD book-cover daemon tattood on my left leg.
>
> http://www.giantfoo.org/~johan/Images/Animals/Humans/johan/BSD-tattoo-1.jpeg
>
> (.... which is copyrighted by Marshall Kirk McKusick)
>
>
> At the end of the day, what really matters (or should really matter) is
> the quality of the project (the OS, code, interactions of the community),
> not the superficial window dressing. But ironically, i think the current
> plan to dump the daemon is just that: change solely for appearances'
> sake. And i doubt many places will suddenly choose NetBSD instead of Linux
> or FreeBSD just because there's no longer a cute little daemon logo.
>
>
> Oh, and what's going to happen to the stuff in here?:
>
> http://www.netbsd.org/gallery/devotionalia.html
>
>
> And is NetBSD still going to accept proceeds of sales of t-shirts with the
> daemon on them?
>
>
> All of that being said, i'm not against any sort of change. I can
> readily understand how the currnet logo could be difficult to reproduce or
> work with. It is complicated and non-trivial to draw. And i can even
> understand how some people might dislike the militaristic Iwo Jima
> reference.
>
> But can we please save the daemon?
>
> -johan