Subject: htdig Package Installation Unhelpful
To: None <netbsd-help@netbsd.org>
From: Nick Boyce <nick@glimmer.demon.co.uk>
List: netbsd-help
Date: 07/15/2003 02:59:09
I just installed the binary package of ht://dig 3.1.6 onto a NetBSD
1.6.1 Apache webserver, and decided that the installation is less than
helpful, in that lots of manual tweaking is required after the install
completes.

1)  /usr/pkg/etc/htdig/htdig.conf contains HTML elements referencing
an alias of "/htdig/" but that alias isn't created by the installer -
no httpd.conf entries are added for htdig.=20

2)  The standard htdig graphics only get installed to
/usr/pkg/share/examples/htdig/, which seems the wrong place - surely
they too would usefully go in /usr/pkg/etc/htdig/.  And there is no
warning of that fact from the installer.

[ I added 'Alias /htdig/ "/usr/pkg/share/examples/htdig/"' to Apache's
config ]

3)  The standard htdig HTML include files (header, footer, etc.) get
installed to /usr/pkg/share/htdig/common, but you have to hunt around
to find that out - again, wouldn't they be better placed in
/usr/pkg/etc/htdig/ ?

It all just feels ... scrappy.

=46inally, because I had umask 027 when I ran "pkg_add htdig*", many of
the htdig directories & files did not have adequate permissions (owner
root:wheel, perms 640) to be accessible by Apache - I had to chmod &
chgrp many many things to make things work.  I'd have thought setting
requisite permissions was one of the installer's jobs .. it should
make no assumptions about the sysadmin's install-time umask.

I only mention all this because it seems the installation experience
could be significantly improved, and am tempted to suggest this in
whatever way is appropriate - but ... I believe the NetBSD way is to
avoid taking automagic actions that may not conform with the
sysadmin's wishes, and leave most configuration to the individual - so
automatic config tweaking might be considered inappropriate (different
folks may use different webserver packages).

I'd be interested in anyone else's opinions on this.

Cheers,

Nick Boyce
Bristol, UK