Subject: Re: bin/17514 bin/sh and -e
To: None <email@example.com, firstname.lastname@example.org>
From: David Laight <email@example.com>
Date: 01/11/2003 16:38:59
On Sat, Jan 11, 2003 at 12:45:05PM +0000, David Laight wrote:
> Some related 'features':
> - the man page (probably incorrectly) that -e only affects
> non-interactive shells. The POSIX defn doesn't mention it under
> -e, but refers to a section which says that a non-interactive
> shell should have exited under many of the error cases even if -e
> wasn't set.
> - although 'false' will cause the shell to exit, (exit 3) doesn't,
> I suspect there are others. (pdksh is also broken here, netbsd's
> shell from 1.5.2 does exit).
> - syntax errors (eg 'for ;') should also cause the shell to exit.
- a command error status picked up in 'fg'
> I'll look into it.
Fixing 'command not found' is relatively easy (just change the 'return'
statement(s) in evalcommand to 'goto out').
However the man page is wrong (ie disagrees with posix).
-e When this option is on, if a simple command fails for any of
the reasons listed in Consequences of Shell Errors or returns an
exit status value >0, and is not part of the compound list following
a while, until, or if keyword, and is not a part of an AND or OR
list, and is not a pipeline preceded by the ! reserved word, then
the shell shall immediately exit.
netbsd's man page says:
-e If not interactive, exit immediately if any untested command fails.
The exit status of a command is considered to be explicitly tested
if the command is used to control an if, elif, while, or until; or
if the command is the left hand operand of an ``&&'' or ``||''
Note that posix says 'simple command' and does not exclude the right
hand part of an && or || operator.
This (probably) means that 'set -e; (exit 1);' should not cause the
shell to exit - because (...) isn't a simple command (and the exit 1
is in a differnt shell).
However in 'false | true' and 'true | false' the 'false' is a simple
command executed by the shell so maybe should cause the shell to exit.
(the fact that pipelines preceeded by ! are specifically mentioned
as not exiting does sort of imply that pipelines not preceeded by !
should exit on error).
pdksh exits on 'true | false', but not on 'false | true'.
Detecting the latter is quite tricky (with the current code) as
the status of the early parts of a pipeline is discarded.
David Laight: firstname.lastname@example.org