Subject: Re: USB keyboard (mis-)support issues...
To: None <lennart@augustsson.net>
From: Matthias Drochner <M.Drochner@fz-juelich.de>
List: current-users
Date: 06/18/2003 19:10:58
lennart@augustsson.net said:
> Just looking at this you can see that the USB keyboard is not your
> console, the PS/2 keyboard is your console. This is a problem with the
> PS/2 keyboard driver that claims there's a PS/2 keyboard even when
> there is none.
Not quite. Console device selection is done early, before autoconfiguration,
based on information passed by the bootloader.
I see 2 ways to resolve this:
a) find out early that the device which looks like a traditional
keyboard (to the BIOS at least) is really a USB keyboard, then either:
- don't call pckbdcnattach(), or
- add an argument to pckbdcnattach() telling it to take the console
for DDB (assuming hardware emulation works), but to abstain
from claiming it at autoconfiguration time
b) in the USB code, find out that the ukbd is emulating a legacy device,
and set up a callback for after autoconfiguration which fixes up things
> I think it should be fixed, but it's not related to the
> USB code
There was sone discussion (or even a PR) suggesting that a pckbd
should even be attached if no hardware was detected in _any_ case.
(Ie, not only if it was designated as console.)
People want to be able to plug in the kbd later.
Of course, the KBC was never designed for hotplugging...
But this is unrelated to console selection, as said.
best regards
Matthias