Subject: Tangent: Current-kernel revision naming...
To: Andrew Brown <firstname.lastname@example.org>
From: Greywolf <email@example.com>
Date: 02/15/2000 16:00:11
On Tue, 15 Feb 2000, Andrew Brown wrote:
# >#### TANGENT!!! ####
# >On the naming convention for releases, should we perhaps start calling
# >them Major.Minor.Patchlevel.NumericRelease? Or would it be too confusing
# >to reference 1.4S as 188.8.131.52 (vs 1.4.1)?
# it should probably be actually be 184.108.40.206, but i'm not sure it'll be
# a popular idea. :)
I figure 220.127.116.11 because 1.4S does NOT branch off 1.4.1, but rather
off 1.4 as a development branch. The reason I thought it would be mis-
leading is because 18.104.22.168 would appear to be a lesser rev than
1.4.1, even though 1.4.*0*, specifically (vs 1.4) could be taken as a
The alternative is to release as major.minor.numeric.patchlevel, so
what is now 1.4.1 would be called 22.214.171.124, and 1.4.1 would be the branch
from current, but that's not entirely sensible either.
# >It would certainly solve the 1.4<letter> convention and save us from
# >running out of chars...
# but instead we'd be using up more. letters are a much more compact
# form of representation.
Yes, but going beyond Z means either going to 'a' as you suggest below,
or going to AA or some other multi-char scheme. The former is confusing
because if you're talking about Maj.minA vs Maj.mina, how do you know
it's not a typo or something? The latter screws up any hope of keeping
__NetBSD_Version__ straight, especially if that version number is
generated as opposed to manually entered. It just opens a whole bag
of spaghetti that way, is all.
Hopefully, though, this will all be moot and we'll hit 1.5 before
we have to go to 1.4Z++.
# btw - what would be wrong with simply going from 1.4Z -> 1.4a? it
# satisfies the ascii sort order, and would fit into the "kernel version
# letter - '@'" methodology.
See above, but it's probably more sane than anything else I've seen
I could see, though that people might wonder what happened to versions
104270000 thru 104640000 :-).
[I'm sorry -- I guess it is kind of silly.]
NetBSD: safe ports in a storm.