Subject: Re: Routed, anyone?
To: Neil J. McRae <email@example.com>
From: Julian Bean <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Date: 03/07/1996 10:05:17
Neil J. McRae wrote:
> On Wed, 6 Mar 1996 22:51:52 +0000
> Julian Bean <email@example.com> wrote:
> > I am trying to use routed to broadcast routing information from my subnet
> > (of two machines) to my ISP.
> > In principle, it works. I log on to my ISP. I am elsie.mailbox.co.uk =
> > 220.127.116.11. Fine. My machine knows that it can also reach
> > tnt.mailbox.co.uk = 18.104.22.168 via its other interface.
> > I set routed running.
> ARG! routed is the son of satan. Why are you using anything but static routes?
> There is no need here to use the routed. Unless your advertising like 40
> different routes. Just put the routes in and leave them.
Perhaps I misunderstand. But surely if I don't run routed, then I'm not advertising
the routes. And I want to advertise the routes, because I don't want to have to get
the root password of my ISP's router, telnet in, and add a static route there.
> > My machine, in 30 seconds or so, broadcasts this route to my ISP's router.
> > So now my ISP's router knows that 22.214.171.124 is reachable vi
> > 126.96.36.199.
> Oh god this is sick.
I have a sick mind ;-)
> > tnt is simply sending all packets via elsie, which has IP-forwarding on.
> > So I have a mac fully on the net via my BSD box. Cool. Everything works
> > (Netscape, Eudora, etc.)
> > But, after three minutes, routed gets bored and decides to delete its route
> > to tnt via ppp1, because it has not heard anything about that route. Then
> > shortly after, the ISP's router deletes its route, and *bang* my powermac
> > is off the net again.
> > I can add the route again simply by typing "route add tnt tnt", but it will
> > go again in three minutes.
> > Anyone know how to tell routed not to delete a particular route, every time?
> Yes, don't run it use static routes.
Don't think this solves my problem.... But if you can tell me how it does....
> > BTW, what's EGP?
> Exterior Gateway Protocol, more evil.
You've really got a thing about dynamic routing, haven't you? I thought dynamic
routing was one of the really clever things about the internet.