Subject: FreeBSD's NFS = 4.4BSD, NetBSD's NFS = Net/2 ???
To: None <current-users@NetBSD.ORG>
From: Ken Nakata <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Date: 05/31/1995 12:21:03
I apologize if current-users isn't a place for this kind of thing.
The following was tossed on fj.os.386bsd, forwarded from a linux group...:
<<included message begins here>>
]From: email@example.com (Alan Cox)
]Subject: Re: freeBSD and Linux networking code (what is different?)
]Organization: Institute For Industrial Information Technology
]Date: Tue, 30 May 1995 16:39:59 GMT
]In article <firstname.lastname@example.org> email@example.com (Richard D. Yentis) writes:
]>I am wondering what are the differences between the two versions of
]>BSD and the Linux networking code. Are they all exactly the same?
]>are Linux and freeBSD the same but the other BSD is newer and/or
]>better? Is there a historical tie between the code? Can someone
]>point out who I might ask to find out?
]NetBSD uses the BSD NET/2 code, from 4.3 BSD series kernels. This is not
]stunningly fast, not stunningly clever, has some odd quirks but is
]incredibly reliable due to its age and design.
]FreeBSD uses the BSD NET/3 code, from 4.4 BSD. This has some pretty serious
]bugs but has good multicast support and other niceities like TCP PAWS
]support. Most but not all of the bugs are in unusual events. It has most
]of the odd limitations of BSD NET/2 as well - eg not being able to use
]RAW sockets to listen to a protocol the kernel understands.
]Linux uses its own scratch written code. As of 1.2.x the code is as reliable
]as BSD (imho), and I run things like a big web server on it. Its also got
]some odd quirks and as few bugs and limitations. In theory it has the scope
]to be faster on PC hardware than the others, but optimisation to really
]make it rip is a 1.3.x project
<<included message ends here>>
I usually don't believe what linux people have to say about BSD, for
they seem to say a lot of bogus things about it. Is this one of those
things, or is NetBSD's NFS code in fact based on Net/2, rather than
4.4 Lite? (not that it's a big deal or anything, since I don't use NFS
on my NetBSD box)
I appreciate if anyone could set me straight.